Historian G.G. Bonser accessed a remarkable 1295 Mansfield Manor rental survey from which he extracted Sutton tenants to claim a total population would probably be about 400. Including Hucknall Huthwaite also among Sutton-in-Ashfield parish registers, Dr. S. T. Hall suggested, beginning the 18th century there were but ninety five families in Sutton, while noting parish clerk Thomas Dove conducted a 1770 door to door census still ambiguously recording families, 270 of whom lived in Sutton plus 80 in Huthwaite. A census taken 1793 by Sir Richard Sutton again included Huthwaite with a slovenly count totalling 3,492.
.
Collating all available Hucknall Huthwaite census numbers can graphically illustrate periods of general industrialised significance.
Year Sutton % Huthwaite 1801 2,801 18.2 510 1811 3,386 18.0 608 1821 3,943 18.0 712 1831 4,805 19.3 929 1841 5,670 15.6 887 1851 6,554 17.6 1,154 1861 6,483 17.9 1,162 1871 7,574 20.4 1,547 1881 8,523 23.8 2,028 1891 10,562 28.6 3,022 1901 14,867 27.4 4,076 1911 21,708 24.1 5,235 1921 23,852 23.0 5,478 1931 25,151 23.2 5,836 1934 25,750 19.9 5,135 1939 1951 1961 27,618 17 4,571 1971 26,850 17 4,570
Taking census every ten years might have shown initial concern about monitoring and feeding the nations recent population boom. Farms populating smaller rural hamlets and villages struggled to support growing numbers of agricultural labourers. Manorial concern encouraged introduction of Frame Work Knitting machines, and that home cottage industry eventually established district renown for hosiery manufacturing.
Parliamentary or UK national census began 1801. After simple head counts, detailed records from 1841 provide useful genealogy reference. Most numbers are extracted from dated gazetteers detailing Hucknall Huthwaite entries. Additional listing of Sutton figures simply compares relative size of Hucknall Huthwaite by calculated percentage.
Digging coal from and around Hucknall Huthwaite can date way before Mellor's larger colliery sees first major jump in numbers populating its Pit Row housing. A steeper rise does nonetheless follow its closure, clearly indicating greater employment by the FWK trade among the communal yards filling out west side the Main Street.
Sharpest 30 year rise from 1880 must of course result from opening the modern New Hucknall Colliery. Management generously contributed in the building of a prospering Huthwaite mining community. Having invited a massive workforce quickly demanding broadest village construction, housing never did manage fully meeting demand. When needing to reduce full time employees, many existing Huthwaite resident families were able to find work in walking distance among other neighbouring collieries.
This long proud mining community should also acknowledge the hosiery industry for adding a final increase reaching 1931 peak. Opening a vast CWS factory transferred only a few key staff from Leicester while certainly enticing other tradesmen. But even if boundary changes and tramway commuters didn't up numbers, this larger factory expanded the hosiery trade, securing family life by also employing young females.
Any hopes towards asserting individual town status would be ultimately dashed by forced abolition of the Huthwaite Urban District Council in 1935. Amalgamation into an enlarged Sutton U.D. plus outbreak of a second world war adds difficulty confirming data for a vaguely defined Huthwaite Ward. Further amalgamation lost some village pride being collectively represented in largest part an electoral Sutton West Ward under an Ashfield District Council. Despite recent loss of all major employment, 2011 suggested the Huthwaite population stood at about 7,500, before recognising the local mining heritage in a renamed Huthwaite and Brierley Ward.